Tests edge cases, boundary conditions, and common misconceptions for vectors.
UT-1: Shortest Distance from a Point to a Line in 3D
Question:
The line l has vector equation r=12−1+t2−13, and the point A has position vector 405.
(a) Find the shortest distance from A to l.
(b) Find the coordinates of the point B on l that is closest to A.
(c) A student attempts to find the distance by computing ∣OA−OP∣ where P is the point on l with t=1. Show that this does not give the shortest distance, and calculate the percentage overestimate.
[Difficulty: hard. Tests the vector projection method for shortest distance from a point to a line in three dimensions.]
Solution:
(a) The line passes through P with position vector p=12−1 and has direction vector d=2−13.
UT-2: Distinguishing Skew, Parallel, and Intersecting Lines in 3D
Question:
Line l1 passes through A(1,2,3) with direction vector d1=2−11.
Line l2 passes through B(4,1,0) with direction vector d2=1a2.
(a) Find the value of a for which l1 and l2 intersect.
(b) For a=3, determine whether l1 and l2 are skew, parallel, or intersecting.
(c) For a=−1, find the shortest distance between l1 and l2.
[Difficulty: hard. Tests the systematic approach to classifying pairs of lines in 3D: parallel (proportional direction vectors), intersecting (solvable system), or skew (inconsistent system with non-parallel directions).]
Solution:
(a)d1 and d2 are not proportional for any value of a (since 12=a−1 for a=−21, and checking: at a=−21, 12=2 but 21=21=2). So the lines are never parallel.
For intersection, there exist s,t such that:
1+2s=4+t,2−s=1+at,3+s=0+2t
From the first equation: t=2s−3.
From the third equation: 3+s=2(2s−3)=4s−6⟹3s=9⟹s=3.
Then t=2(3)−3=3.
Substituting into the second equation: 2−3=1+3a⟹−1=1+3a⟹a=−32.
The lines intersect when a=−32, at the point 1+62−33+3=7−16.
(b) For a=3: the lines are not parallel (d1 and d2 not proportional). Check for intersection:
t=2s−3, s=3, t=3 (from first and third equations).
Second equation: 2−3=1+3(3)=10, giving −1=10, which is false.
The system is inconsistent, so the lines are skew.
(c) For a=−1: the lines are skew (checking as above gives −1=1+(−1)(3)=−2, false).
UT-3: Angle Between Two Planes Using Normal Vectors
Question:
Plane Π1 has equation 2x−y+2z=5 and plane Π2 has equation x+2y−2z=3.
(a) Find the acute angle between Π1 and Π2.
(b) Find the equation of the line of intersection of Π1 and Π2 in vector form.
(c) A student claims that the angle between the planes equals the angle between their normal vectors without taking the acute angle. Explain why this is not always correct.
[Difficulty: hard. Tests the angle between planes via their normals, and finding the line of intersection by solving a system.]
Solution:
(a) Normal to Π1: n1=2−12. Normal to Π2: n2=12−2.
n1⋅n2=2−2−4=−4
∣n1∣=4+1+4=3,∣n2∣=1+4+4=3
cosθ=L◆B◆∣n1⋅n2∣◆RB◆◆LB◆∣n1∣∣n2∣◆RB◆=94
θ=arccos(94)
Note the absolute value in the numerator: the angle between planes is defined as the acute angle, so we take ∣−4∣=4.
(b) The line of intersection has direction vector d=n1×n2:
d=i21j−12k2−2=2−4−(−4−2)4+1=−265
To find a point on both planes, set z=0:
2x−y=5 and x+2y=3. Solving: from the first, y=2x−5.
x+2(2x−5)=3⟹5x=13⟹x=513, y=51.
Point: (513,51,0).
Line of intersection: r=13/51/50+t−265.
(c) The angle between two planes is always taken as the acute angle (between 0 and L◆B◆π◆RB◆◆LB◆2◆RB◆). The angle between the normal vectors can be obtuse (between L◆B◆π◆RB◆◆LB◆2◆RB◆ and π). In this problem, the dot product is negative (−4), so the angle between the normals is obtuse: arccos(−4/9)≈116.4°. The acute angle between the planes is 180°−116.4°=63.6°=arccos(4/9).
The student must always take the acute angle, which is why the absolute value is needed in the cosine formula.
Wait, this gives t=11/6, not t=1. Let me re-check the claim.
At t=11/6: D2=12(121/36)−44(11/6)+107=361452−2904+3852=362400=3200.
At t=1: D2=12−44+107=75. D=53.
At t=11/6: D=200/3=L◆B◆106◆RB◆◆LB◆3◆RB◆≈8.16.
At t=1: D=75=53≈8.66.
So the minimum is at t=11/6, not t=1. The question's claim is incorrect. The ships are closest at t=11/6 hours.
Let me verify: dt2d2(D2)=24>0, confirming a minimum.
Minimum distance: D=200/3=L◆B◆106◆RB◆◆LB◆3◆RB◆ km.
Note: The question asks to "show that the ships are closest at t=1 hour," but this is false. The actual closest approach occurs at t=611 hours. Recognising incorrect claims is itself a diagnostic skill.
The ships are never exactly 5 km apart. The minimum distance is L◆B◆106◆RB◆◆LB◆3◆RB◆≈8.16 km, which exceeds 5 km.
IT-3: Proving a Geometric Theorem Using Vectors (with Proof)
Question:
(a) Using vectors, prove that the diagonals of a parallelogram bisect each other.
(b) The medians of a triangle ABC are the line segments from each vertex to the midpoint of the opposite side. Using position vectors with origin O, prove that the three medians of triangle ABC are concurrent at a point G (the centroid), and that G divides each median in the ratio 2:1.
(c) Points P and Q have position vectors p and q respectively. Show that the midpoint of PQ has position vector L◆B◆p+q◆RB◆◆LB◆2◆RB◆, and use this result to prove that the line segment joining the midpoints of two sides of a triangle is parallel to the third side and half its length.
[Difficulty: hard. Uses vector methods to prove classical geometric theorems, requiring careful position vector and midpoint reasoning.]
Solution:
(a) Let the parallelogram have vertices A, B, C, D with position vectors a, b, c, d.
Since ABCD is a parallelogram, AB=DC:
b−a=c−d⟹a+c=b+d
The midpoint of diagonal AC: L◆B◆a+c◆RB◆◆LB◆2◆RB◆.
The midpoint of diagonal BD: L◆B◆b+d◆RB◆◆LB◆2◆RB◆.
Since a+c=b+d, these midpoints coincide. Therefore the diagonals bisect each other.
(b) Let the vertices of triangle ABC have position vectors a, b, c.
The midpoint of BC has position vector L◆B◆b+c◆RB◆◆LB◆2◆RB◆.
The median from A to the midpoint of BC has equation: